|
Tuesday, July 18, 2006
Come On Hear the Illinois  Cooler-than-thou hipsters rejoice! The backlash against Sufjan Stevens is in full force. This will surely buy him a few more years on top of the cool-to-name-drop list. The recent barrage started with an article on All Music Guide, one that's been circulating around the blogosphere. The writer argues that Sufjan's brand of folk-pop is boring, pedestrian, and overly-pretentious, the heaps of critical acclaim undeserved. Even his thorough research on the subject matters of his songs was thought to be high-school-y; apparently, this writer thinks art shouldn't be mixed with a methodical process. Picking up on the article, other blogs -- even Zolius -- nodded their heads in agreement.
Of course, I can defend Sufjan. (I like The Avalanche, though not as much as Seven Swans.) But I choose not to, as I'm sure you've read plenty of those kinds of posts already. What I am going to say is that this has extended his shelf life on the Hipster-Approved List of Cool Music.
Let me first differentiate between Hipster Cool and Indie Yuppie Cool. The former refers to Pitchfork-like taste-masters and their devote followers, while the latter refers to people who take their music cues from The OC (at least up until last season). Bands like Death Cab are still cool for the latter though not for the former, and bands like Les Savy Fav are cool for the former, but not even on the radar of the latter. We're on the same page now, right? Good.
Now, when a band gets too popular without a significant backlash, their popularity among hipsters will inevitably decline (not among indie yuppies though). Even the band that can do no wrong -- Radiohead -- took some major hits with their adventurous Kid A record. A lot of people hated it, which made people who loved it even more vocal in professing their affection for it. That bit of backlash allowed their future works to be praised, since no band can carry on indefinitely without a goodly amount of hatin' from time to time. Even in the world of critical acclaim, there is such a thing as "too much."
With Sufjan knocked down a peg, tastemakers like Pitchfork will be free to laud the next instalment of his 50-State project. They won't feel compel to bash it since someone's already done the work for them. The praise will serve as the counterpoint to all the haters, a staunch defence of a cooler-than-thou artist. It won't sound like the same-old tune. Likewise, hipsters will allow themselves to love it too since he won't be overexposed. I, of course, will adore it too as long as the quality of the music stays high. I classify myself as an unabashed music geek because I love music, not hipster points. That's why mine is one of the few blogs that can't stop talking about Nina Gordon.
But for The Arcade Fire's future as hipster darlings, someone needs to bash Funeral. Like, now.
NP: (nothing)
posted by Hanson |
7/18/2006 12:54:00 AM
|