Ripping off Mary Lou Lord...
Thursday, June 22, 2006

Critiquing Critiques

Aaron over at pop (all love) doesn't update often, but when he does, it's almost always a gem. His piece today on the inability for annual music awards to recognize future classics -- instead opting to honour flavours of the month -- is spot on. As evidence, he pointed to the winners of the Mercury Prize, Britain's annual hipster-approved top album award. M People, Roni Size, and Ms. Dynamite: not exactly The Beatles, eh?

The post goes on to suggest that an album should be left to age a few years before being given the big critical stamp of approval. Will Illinois and Funeral stand the test of time? Only, um, time will tell.

I can't disagree with the "have-to-let-it-age" theory of music criticism. Coincidentally, Matt and I were talking about just that today. Since the end of last year, my evaluation of Wolf Parade's Apologies to the Queen Mary has risen steadily, probably due to the fact that I've spent more time listening to it. On the other end of the spectrum is (at the time) my second favourite record of 2002, Phantom Planet's The Guest. That album probably hasn't been in my CD player (or iTunes) in a year, and while I still think it's a nice little record, I doubt it'd be anywhere close to number two if I were to redo that list today.

In fact, looking back at my list of favourites of 2002, I play only about five of them with any regularity now (Bright Eye's Lifted..., Patty Griffin's 1000 Kisses, Pedro the Lion's Control, Pretty Girls Make Graves' Good Health, and Ladytron's Light & Magic). Now, that probably has something to do with my subtly-shifting taste in music -- that Kay Hanley solo record just doesn't do much for me anymore -- but one cannot discount the impact of the "recency effect" on the making of Best-Of lists. (Hello Oscars!)

Will that stop me from doing my annual Top 37 lists? Probably not. I pretty much know it's an exercise in bullshit, but it's fun bullshit. I mean, if not for that, what are blogs for anyway?

PS: Go Aussies!

NP: Park Ave - She's an Actress?

posted by Hanson | 6/22/2006 11:55:00 PM | 

the ho
Check Out My Balls
mo' ho
seeing
to be updated
past shows
listening
last week:
mostly music
reading
links
archives