Ripping off Mary Lou Lord...
Friday, March 03, 2006

Bad Bad Blogs

In the interest of full disclosure, let me preface this by saying that I look forward to albums leaking online months before the release date. I also steal download music quite a bit. Still, there's something I've got to get off my chest...

Nick Sylvester is one of the few Pitchfork reviewers that I almost always agree with. In his blog post yesterday on the Village Voice website, he was spot on again. This time, he aimed squarely at the bow of blogs that do little more than post entire albums without even the slightest attempt at original commentary. The mere existence of such blogs took me by surprise; I mean, aren't blogs just an excuse for Joe Schmoes (like yours truly) to rant about any and everything? Seriously, I really don't see the purpose of blogging if I can't use it as an outlet to shoot my mouth off.

The whole deal with posting readily available albums in their entirety also irks me. (Rarities are a different story.) Here, I post a couple -- maybe three -- tracks at a time. They are meant for people to sample the artists I blog about. Ideally, if they liked what they heard, they'll go pick up an album or go see a show, which puts money in the pockets of people who make great music. The #1 reason why I blog about music is because I can't keep my opinions to myself; the #2 reason why I blog about music is to help promote artists that I like.

Now, one can argue that by posting entire albums, one is furthering reason #2. I don't happen to agree. It's true that these blogs "get the music out," but it also hurts the artists in the long run because they make music as disposable as last night's newspaper. Dig this: by making full albums available with just a few mouse clicks, it makes it way too easy. I mean, downloading music already isn't rocket surgery, but usually, you'd at least have to search for the music that you want. If I want to get Bitter Tea before the street date, I would have to make an effort by searching for it. It isn't hard, but it requires a deliberate action from me to get something that I consciously want. To have it come to me via a blog feed without me having to consciously think of getting it, well, that's just too easy. Hell, I don't even have to really want it to get it; it's just there, so why not? It cheapens the music-getting experience -- even more so than downloading via BitTorrent or Soulseek -- and it makes each piece of music that much more replaceable and disposable in this, a generation of super-sized iPods in shuffle mode.

Crazy-easy downloading also allows people to accumulate music for the sake of being cred. Downloading has already spawned the indie yuppie; crazy-easy downloading will make them multiply exponentially. Indie Yuppie A: "Have you heard the new Wolf! Wolf! Wolf! record?" Indie Yuppie B: "Yeah, I got it last night from Daily Downloadz. I'll let you know how I feel about it once Pitchfork posts its review." You don't even have to try anymore -- just download everything and you'll probably have the latest blog heroes when they start blowing up.

I love site like Fluxblog and You Ain't No Picasso because they introduce me to music, not give it away like some desperate, lonely, drunk girl at closing time. If Matt had posted the entire Eames Era catalogue, I probably would've been less inclined to order it from Insound right away. Sure, I might've tried to find their records at local record stores, but chances are, I would've probably forgotten about it after a few failed attempts. And I'm very good about buying records from artists that I like even though I have them downloaded. (That's the benefit of working for The Man.) My not having the music that I craved forced me into action, and because of that, a few dollars drifted into the pockets of some worthy individuals. Also, I had to work for it, meaning that I'll probably be less likely to just get it and forget it. To me, the music means more when I have to jump through hoops to get it, even if it just means buying it off the internet.

Good music blogs have personalities. They act as filters for those with similar tastes. Blogs that indiscriminately post entire albums don't serve that purpose -- they just seem like automatons that further piracy in the worst way. If people want to download, at least make them work for it (a little bit).

OK. I'll get off my high horse now...

NP: Jenny Lewis and the Watson Twins - Rise Up With Fists

posted by Hanson | 3/03/2006 12:06:00 AM | 

the ho
Check Out My Balls
mo' ho
seeing
to be updated
past shows
listening
last week:
mostly music
reading
links
archives