Ripping off Mary Lou Lord...
Tuesday, October 18, 2005

She Didn't Steal Your Boyfriend

Modest Mouse selling cars. Mainstream radio playing Bright Eyes. Hollywood movies featuring The Shins. The OC. What's next, the New York Times running reviews by Tiny Mix Tape contributors? Most of the current buzz about the merging of the indie scene with the pop mainstream has been focused on how our underground heroes are getting national exposure and slowly migrating to greener major-label pastures. What is often missed in such coverage is the flipside -- how the pop mainstream has taken cues from the indie scene. Exhibit #1: Ashlee Simpson's new single, "Boyfriend."

Say what you will about Ashlee. Is she's a moderately attractive girl with a wholly unremarkable voice who rode her sister's fame to a career in music? Yup. Can you put a thousand other American teens in her position and get the same result? Probably. Will she be selling out arenas in twenty years? Unlikely. But does that change the fact that her new song is only a few steps away from being a dance-y indie-rock hit destined for a 6.4 from Pitchfork? Na uh. Imagine this song with new lyrics, looser production, perhaps a new synth line, sung by a dude in a nice suit or with a big whitey-fro', and it's virtually indistinguishable from the dozens of interchangeable mp3s that permeate the music blogosphere.

It's not surprising, really. The mainstream has always stolen ideas from outsider culture. Almost everything that's popular now used to be "cool" in one subculture or another. Hell, rap used to be protest music, not the soundtrack to ho's and bling. It's not Ashlee's fault that your precious indie sound is being chewed up and spit out just in time for the Christmas season. That's pop culture -- it's an unstoppable, unending process of finding something at the bleeding edge of culture and flogging it until it becomes as lame as "for shizzle my nizzile." Capital fuels the process for sure, but the mainstream's short attention span has a lot to do with it too.

When frat boy jocks are moshing to the Killers, you know the end is near. So what's next? If "indie" is the new "alternative", where do hipsters go from here? Well, Pitchfork seems to be digging the new t.A.T.u., Robyn, and Rachel Stevens, so...

NP: (nothing)

posted by Hanson | 10/18/2005 12:57:00 AM | 

the ho
Check Out My Balls
mo' ho
seeing
to be updated
past shows
listening
last week:
mostly music
reading
links
archives