Ripping off Mary Lou Lord...
Thursday, September 29, 2005

Sub-Par Pop

Those that know me know my disdain for heavy-handed production (for music). But whatever opinions I or anybody else may have on the likes of Max Martin and The Matrix, it's undeniable that they do their job well, churning out a hit parade of glossy, mainstream pop music. At times, I take this type of slick, mainstream production for granted, thinking that all mainstream radio pop songs have equally "good" production. However, I was recently reminded of how completely false that statement was. For proof, one needs to look no further than the new Canadian Idol single.

The song in question is "Alive," sung by the newly crowned Canadian Idol, Melissa O'Neil. As a song, it's your typical schmaltzy Idol fare, perhaps a little better than its predecessors. However, the production for the version they're playing on the radio completely blows chunks. The song, with a catchier-than-average chorus, has the potential to rock out Kelly Clarkson style. But instead of playing to its strengths (i.e. nailing and building around the chorus), it just drifts aimlessly, going nowhere in 3ish minutes. The producers should've unleashed Melissa on the chorus -- something that she does really well -- instead of holding her back just enough to make it completely boring. If they had gotten their Matrix-on, it could've been a sizable (Canadian) hit...

Ben Lee is playing Richard's the same night as Liz Phair -- November 11th. Boo. Maybe if it's an early show, I can catch them both.

Scout Niblett is at the Brickyard Oct. 1st. If I didn't have more important things to do, I'd totally be there.

NP: Metric - Poster of a Girl

posted by Hanson | 9/29/2005 01:15:00 AM | 

the ho
Check Out My Balls
mo' ho
seeing
to be updated
past shows
listening
last week:
mostly music
reading
links
archives