Ripping off Mary Lou Lord...
Sunday, May 23, 2004

The Shins Were the Shiznit

Chaos can be a beautiful thing -- or it could just be pretty messed up. Both sides were on display at the Shins show at the Commodore on Friday, though neither involved said headliners.

Opening the show was US Maple, a band I've heard nothing about before Friday. Their frontman looked like a balding Chris Parnell, his hairy stomach exposed behind his too-small polo shirt that looked like it was made from an oversized tan bath towel. He mumbled into the mic with his hands covering it, barely audible behind the fuzzed out dual guitars. I couldn't look at him for more than five seconds without bursting into laughter. As I told Val, he looked like Chris Parnell trying to be a serious rock star but looking like a fool.

His band mates were no less funny. The guitarist on his left looked like Sebastian Bach with a bowl haircut that grew too long. Wearing a grey suit, he had these rock star kick-and-spin moves that looked pretty stupid. The other guitarist had some chops, but he too was clownish. He had this drugged-out half grin throughout the show, not to mention dance moves that were, uhm, odd. He looked like he could've been a German character actor named Fritz. Or Hans. No no, Fritz. It's gotta be Fritz.

As for their music, it was, as I said, a mess. Song bled into song -- literally -- and I had no idea when to start clapping. That's not always bad, as I've been known to dig some experimental stuff. But these guys were just mathy without being interesting, and I couldn't get into it at all.

On the flip side were The Fiery Furnaces, a band that I was looking forward to seeing. Like US Maple, their set was equally paced, as they too didn't stop between songs. But amidst the chaos was a clarity; the coherence that was lacking in structure was made up in style. Their brand of rootsy Quasi-meets-Unicorns quirk doesn't sound like anything that's out there, and their live show was no different.

Singer/guitarist Eleanor Friedberger played with such deliberate ferocity, it almost covered up her otherwise shy demeanour. Banter was virtually nonexistent, and you had a feeling that they wanted to squeeze as much music into their 40 minutes as possible. That they did, playing parts of 18 different songs during their short set. In fact, the epic 10+ minute Quay Cur, the opening track to their new album Blueberry Boat, was broken up into three pieces and scattered throughout the set. I've never seen anything like it. In a sense, their show was what you'd get after they've been put through a blender. It was a disassembled mess individually, but taken as a whole, it was perfectly coherent -- and fucking brilliant.

And then there were The Shins. Instead of having lackeys set up their stuff, James Mercer et al did it themselves, tuning and adjusting as if Chutes Too Narrow didn't sell 100,000+ copies -- an amazing number for a album on Sub Pop. They keepin' it realz! Friday was the first time I've seen them at a club; the previous two times I saw them were at Bumbershoot last year and the year before when they were playing a stadium and an arena, respectively. Unfortunately, the Commodore show had sound that was just as bad as the big venues', and I could hardly hear James' vocals, a strong and distinctive presence on all of The Shins' recordings. That sucked big time.

Still, my favourite band from New Mexico put on a great show. And for once, the fans were really into it too, loudly singing along to songs like Kissing the Lipless and Young Pilgrim. And judging from the crowd's enthusiasm, I'm guessing there was a hardcore contingent that came from the states to see them. I've rarely seen Vancouverites that excited over a band, and I couldn't help but suspect that a bunch of 19 and 20 year-olds decided to cross the border on a Friday night to see their favourite band.

A funny thing happened when James screwed up the lyrics to Pink Bullets. Fans immediately barked out and reminded him of his mistake. Sheepishly, he aborted the song and restarted. Otherwise, the set went off without a hitch -- and they fucking ruled, bad sound notwithstanding. Yay Shins!

NP: Juliana Hatfield - Get a Line

posted by Hanson | 5/23/2004 09:25:00 PM | 

the ho
Check Out My Balls
mo' ho
seeing
to be updated
past shows
listening
last week:
mostly music
reading
links
archives