Tuesday, May 04, 2004
All Hung Up Over Nothing
This PopMatters article really encapsulates my feelings towards the whole William Hung phenomenon. It makes some interesting points about masculinity and the (North) American-Asian male, rejecting the kind of outright and unqualified lambasting the poor guy and his rise to "stardom" have received from the likes of him and him. A few excerpts:
"Asian American men long been largely deprived of sexual self-definition, a result of white paranoia over the sexual and economic threat posed by early Asian American "bachelor societies" (the product of racist immigration and labor policies) and the more recent rise of Asian national economies. When these tensions erupt into media, the resultant images of Asian masculinity are almost always cast in emasculated and/or villainous terms. As a result, the sexual capital of Asian American straight men stands near zero."
"But to reject Hung wholesale as just another casualty of America's racist imagination is to see only part of the picture. Whether we find him stereotypical or not, Hung and people like him are part of the Asian American community. People who speak with accents, people who wear pocket protectors. By failing to claim them, we are conceding to mainstream culture the power to define us."
"More importantly, what Ng and others forget is that Hung has struck a chord with so many, not just because he fits into a familiar stereotype, but because he showed fortitude, and yes, grace, in the face of rejection. It was his humility, not his race, that made him stand out from the parade of crybabies and divas churning through the American Idol machine. Despite his awkward appearance, voice and dance moves, Hung dared to put his dream to the test. He may have been delusional, or simply naïve, but he tried. And then, when he failed, he took it "like a man.""
"The problem is that Hung's critics are so invested in traditional ideas of masculinity (and Asian American men's exclusion from them) that they can't see the disruptive possibilities of Hung's stardom. Guillermo rages, "What is Hung but an infantilized, incompetent and impotent male image? Strong? No. Virile? No. Sexy? The guy's a virgin." (Virgins inherently unsexy? Since when?) With these narrow-minded conceptions of masculinity, it's no wonder Guillermo thinks that Hung's fans can only be out for ridicule. He's so focused on claiming machismo for Asian American men that he can't recognize that perhaps it's masculinity, not Hung, that needs a makeover."
Yeah, what he she said.
NP: Bright Eyes and Neva Dinova - Spring Cleaning
posted by Hanson |
5/04/2004 11:43:00 PM
|