Tuesday, December 23, 2003
Top 37 of 2003: Part III
From here on, it gets hard. 21 to 23 are basically tied. In fact, from 23 to 11, the differences between the albums in that range are not that great at all. Such is the flaw of ranking. Ah well:
25. Cerys Matthews - Cockahoop
Usually, the solo debut apple doesn't fall far from the band's musical tree. Cockahoop is an exception, and aside from Cerys' idiosyncratic voice, it doesn't sound much like Catatonia at all. Maybe recording in Nashville gave the Welsh lass an idea or too, as the album sounds more CMT than NME. Banjos, fiddles, and oboes accompany acoustic guitars, and they all form a minimally-produced musical backdrop for that big, big voice of that she has. You bet it's a departure, from the production all the way to the instrumentation. It does have the Catatonia staple song-in-Welsh though! Still, I don't think it sold well in the UK, but it's at least a good album
24. Sarah McLachlan - Afterglow
Aye. The return of the One. I remember eagerly waiting for Surfacing in 1997, buying it on the same day as I saw the first Men in Black. After listening to it, I was in denial. "No, it doesn't suck that badly," I kept telling myself. It wasn't until after a year or so that I admitted that, save for a few songs, it *did* suck overall. My heart was broken. How could the person responsible for Fumbling Towards Ecstasy, my favourite album in the history of music (at that time), put out something as insipid and uninspiring as this? After listening to Afterglow, I realize that it wasn't Sarah's fault -- well, not entirely anyway. Surfacing *did* suck, but in 1997, I was also slowly diversifying my taste in music, and middle-of-the-road piano-pop just wasn't as appealing as it was before. Fast forward to 2003: Afterglow. Now, the magic is pretty much gone. It's still a decent album with some pretty good songs, many of which I enjoy and sing along to. It's definitely an improvement over Surfacing, but to me, it's just another album -- not something special like FTE or Solace. No, it's not like she mailed it in, but it doesn't reach the such great heights of FTE. With that said, I have a feeling that if FTE were released today, my reaction to it would be different compared to how I felt ten years ago. *sigh*. I guess I've moved on.
23. New Pornographers - Electric Version
Vancouver's preeminent supergroup, they are to Van City what Broken Social Scene is to the Tee Dot, albeit more like a band and less like a "collective." Carl Newman is class, and throw in a little of that sassy Neko Case, and you've got yourself an instant hit. Neko blends more into this one than their previous release, sharing vocal duties on a lot more songs and singing a lot more harmonies and back-ups. This is power-pop at its best, upbeat and free of the faux-angst of modern radio rock. Now this is the kind of porno I can sink my teeth into!
22. Unicorns - Who Will Cut Our Hair When We're Gone?
Quirky. No, that's not fair. True, that word aptly describes the Unicorns' style, but it's an oversimplification. Special. Yes, that's it. How else would you describe an indie pop band that spits on the face of the tried-and-true pop song structure of verse-chorus-verse? Cheerfully inventive tunes, both lyrically and musically, about death, ghosts, and other things, all done using various beeps and sounds accompanying your basic band equipment. It's surprising hummable given the unstructured nature of the songs: no choruses to speak of, just long, 2-4 minute song that don't repeat parts. It's a remarkable achievement, honestly, and bonus marks for defying conventions! And double bonus marks for name-dropping Biggie Smalls.
21. Danny Michel - Tales From the Invisible Man
At a time when the likes of John Mayer and Jason Mraz reigns supreme, why isn't there room on the radio for the genius that is Danny Michel? Stylistically, this M covers a lot more ground than the other two M's: a one trick pony, he is not. This album goes from alt-country (Thunder in the Mountain) to IDM-lite (Full Effect) to big band (Would You Buy a Frame?) to low-tempo-melodrama (The Invisible Man) to piano-sap (The Luckiest Man in the World), but mostly, it's upbeat guitar-pop with a whole lot of back up. Basically, Tales From the Invisible Man is a sonic roller coaster, one that will have you lining up for seconds.
NP: Nada Surf - La Pour Ca
posted by Hanson |
12/23/2003 01:32:00 PM
|