Friday, March 28, 2003
(A Long One On) Post-Traditionalism
As a computing and marketing student, I don't get fed the large dosage of post-*ism that most arts students have to deal with, my newly-acquired Canadian Studies minor notwithstanding. That being said, please let me know if there's already a term for what I'm going to describe.
I just finished watching part three of a three-part documentary on PBS about Chinese-Americans, their history, experiences, that kind of thing. There's some really interesting stuff about the older first-gen Americans who are now in the 50s, their struggles against racism, growing up "different," and all that jazz. But the real meat came when the thoroughly Americanized twentysomethings were trotted out.
They talked of lofty parental expectations, strict codes of conduct, pressures to succeed in school, a "pervasive fog of guilt and disappointment," and the compelling need to fit into the stereotypical model minority. Not only that, they dropped terms like FOB, twinkies, etc.: keywords familiar to most people of my demographic. [aside: but in front of whitey? how dare they!!] Basically, they were typical "bananas" that grew up in traditional Chinese households.
As a self-centred egoist, I brought it all back to myself. While I recognize the similarities between what I was seeing and what I saw in myself, I couldn't help but notice how different we were. First of all, pressures that I had to succeed in school: nil. Not that I was so dumb that expecting success was unmerited, it’s just that marks were never really a concern in my household. In elementary and early in junior high, I basically got straight B’s except for A’s in Math (duh) and quirky stuff like Drama and PE. That was never an issue, and I was never made to feel bad or anything. Well, except for my horrendous handwriting. *That* was always a monkey on my back. Anyway, the no-pressure strategy worked, as by the end of high school, I got scholarships and ended up with straight A’s except for a B in friggin’ French 11 (Madam Schimmel was out to get me, I swear). I also got accepted directly into the only school/program I applied for: Computing Science at SFU.
Even my choice of post-secondary studies was my own. Yes yes, I realize I’m doing both of the popular Chinese subjects, computing and business, but I’m doing a double major here! Most would just do joints (the non-smokeable ones) because it’s easier. My insisting on not being half-assed is actually not that typical among the stereotypical cmptsci/business Chinese guy. I was basically free to study what I want, and med and law schools were never even suggested to me. In fact, if anything, my dad discouraged me from becoming a lawyer because, as he said, they have to live by the law and not by their own values. Good shit.
I was also never compared to other people’s kids. I never got the “so and so got this and that, so why can’t you get this and that too” spiel, and as far as I know, they didn’t use my brother and I as symbols of success (though they easily could have) in front of their friends. Not that they weren’t proud of us; they would display our trophies, attended our plays, and made it known that they were proud: it’s just they didn’t need to do it publicly to *prove* to their peers that we were the shit.
Instead of being taught to ruthlessly drive for success, I was taught patience and sportsmanship. In fact, “congratulations” was one of the first English words I knew! I was taught that word after playing Monopoly (Hong Kong edition, of course) when I was 6. Shake hands and say “congratulations” after I lose my last dime was a tradition. Air-conditioned flat on a hot Hong Kong summer day. Congratulations. I still remember it like it was yesterday.
Another difference between the TV-people and me was that they were very westernized growing up. Their parents force-fed Chinese qualities to them and told them they should be proud to be Chinese just because, and all the while they themselves were trying to be as American as possible. That hypocrisy was the exact opposite of my upbringing: I was brought up on Chinese literature, Chinese values, and Chinese culture. What I did with what I was taught was my own business, and I wasn’t made to wave the Chinese flag without question. In other words, my cultural identity was cultivated from within while theirs was painted on with a big Made in America paintbrush. Naturally, they jerked, and the paint cracked. For me, the roots grew so deep, I couldn’t imagine myself being anything else.
Why were our experiences so different? I think it’s because my parents weren’t the “white worshipers” that their parents were. My mom and dad didn’t aspire to whiteness by adopting white customs, values, religions, etc. My parents were among the few Chinese intellectuals who didn’t think that the West is the shit. While acknowledging some of the good points about Western culture, they nevertheless kept a lot of traditional Chinese customs that many so-called “educated” people of Hong Kong reject simply on the grounds that they are relics from a “backwards” culture. Things like a shrine dedicated to ancestors and demigods (a “sun toi”) and Chinese herbal remedies are a common place in the Ho household. The same cannot be said of many Chinese professionals though.
A synthesis of the thesis of the traditional Chinese and the antithesis of the westernized Chinese, the necessary progression from Chinese traditionalism is naturally the post-traditionalism that I was brought up with. No burden, no guilt: just good cultural stuff.
Hmm…. this has turned into a bit of a rambling here…. I hope I was somewhat coherent :-)
NP: Jason Mraz - The Remedy (I Won't Worry)
posted by Hanson |
3/28/2003 02:01:00 AM
|