Ripping off Mary Lou Lord...
Wednesday, December 18, 2002

Roger Ebert: The Asswiping Asswipe

Anger... simmering.... rage... boiling.... want... to... explode!

Fucking Roger Ebert. Now, you know I don't swear often (ah, who am I kidding?), but this Ebert fellow, he pisses me off. Quite a bit. So instead of praising the resounding and transcending magnificence that is The Two Towers, I'm going to pull a Dennis Miller and rant about this mofo (although much less eloquently).

So, I opened the newspaper today to read the review(s) for The Two Towers, a movie I had the pleasure of enjoying at midnight last night. The rag that I read, the Province (hold your snickers people! I read it for the sports and entertainment stuff, really!), runs reviews from Mr. Famous Critic Roger Ebert. When I saw that he gave the movie 3 stars, I thought to myself: guarded praise... oh boy... here we go.

The next thing I read was something to the effect of "good but doesn't capture the spirit of Tolkien." Spirit of Tolkien! Spirit of Tolkien!! SPIRIT OF TOLKIEN!!! How, uber-critic, do you know SPIRIT OF TOLKIEN!! Do you know him? Does he call you at home? Do you have a dorsal fin!?!

He then goes on to say that there wasn't enough hobbit stuff and that Big Pete basically spoilt the intention of Ronald and turned the film into big-ass swashbuckling adventure. Well la dee da, nugget-brained wannabe-elitist! What do you think a movie based on a book that centres around a big-ass battle was supposed to be?? *two-finger salute*

With The Lord of the Rings, Tolkien, IMO, set out to create a pseudo-mythology. It was not, as Ebert implied, supposed to be whimsical tale about how nice little hobbits triumphed over the big bad; rather, it was an epic to end all epics: the ultimate battle of Good vs. Evil. Surely, little things overcoming big things *is* a theme, but the way the story is told, that was certainly not the main theme of The Two Towers (hell, Shelob was even pushed back to the next film!). At its heart, LOTR is an action/adventure, and TTT movie lives up to that and then some.

Helms Deep and the drowning of Isengard were two tentpole events of the book, and I have no complaints of how they were translated on to celluloid. Ebert seems to think they spent too much time on the battle scenes; well, Mr. Ebert, how the fuck would YOU have done it? Spent more time shooting Frodo and company walking around? *More* on the "weight" of the Ring? Sit yo ass down, foo, and let the man do his work!

The Battle of Hornburg and the Ents were the two things I was especially looking forward to, and I can't see PJ cutting any part of what was left in there. The film was already 3 hours long, and to add more hobbit stuff (not that I would mind) without cutting what was already in there would make the film even longer (duh!), and that probably wouldn't sit well with the casual fan.

I'll post a less ranty bit about the film after my second viewing tonight :-)

NP: Rilo Kiley - My Slumbering Heart

posted by Hanson | 12/18/2002 02:22:00 PM | 

the ho
Check Out My Balls
mo' ho
seeing
to be updated
past shows
listening
last week:
mostly music
reading
links
archives